Hellfire OddsOdds calculator
The Butcher

The Butcher

The Butcher is a unique monster (demon) of dungeon level 2 in Diablo and Hellfire. It can drop 29 unique items; the most likely in Hellfire multiplayer, Normal, are Baranar's Star and 16 others, 0.432% (1 in 231) per kill.

Kind
Unique monster (demon)
Dungeon levels
2
Item level of its drops
5 on every difficulty
Bases it drops
up to level 6 on Normal, 21 on Nightmare, 36 on Hell
Game
Diablo and Hellfire
Quest
The Butcher

As a unique monster it always drops one item, with good affixes only, and that item is unique 16 times out of 100 when a unique of its base can exist at that level. In Solo (in multiplayer only with the “Full quests in Multiplayer” option) it drops The Butcher's Cleaver instead on Normal, and a random axe on Nightmare and Hell.

Odds for your own character

Unique items it drops · Hellfire, multiplayer

Unique itemBase itemNormalNightmareHell
Baranar's StarMorning Star0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Black RazorDagger0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Blackoak ShieldSmall Shield0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Civerb's CudgelMace0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Constricting RingRing0.432% (1 in 231)0.658% (1 in 152)0.632% (1 in 158)
Ice ShankLong Sword0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
ImmolatorLong Staff0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Leather of AutLeather Armor0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Split Skull ShieldBuckler0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Blackoak BowLong Bow0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The DefenderSabre0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Executioner's BladeFalchion0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The NeedlerShort Bow0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Rainbow CloakCloak0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Torn Flesh of SoulsRags0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Wicked AxeLarge Axe0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Wisdom's WrapRobe0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
BloodSlayerBroad Axe—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Bow of the DeadComposite Bow—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Dragon's BreachKite Shield—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Gibbous MoonBroad Sword—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Hammer of JholmMaul—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Helm of SpiritsHelm—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Celestial AxeBattle Axe—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Celestial StarFlail—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)

Chance per kill of each unique item, in brackets as “1 in N” kills. A dash: the unique cannot drop on that difficulty (Solo: a unique is skipped while the later uniques of its base were not found since you started or loaded the game).

Solo · Hellfire

Unique itemBase itemNormalNightmareHell
The Butcher's Cleaver (once per game)Cleaver100%1 game for 50%——
Stonecleaver (once per game)Broad Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
The Celestial Axe (once per game)Battle Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
Wicked Axe (once per game)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
BloodSlayer (once per game) (after 1 later unique of its base)Broad Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
Sharp Beak (once per game) (after 1 later unique of its base)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
The Mangler (once per game) (after 2 later uniques of its base)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%

Chance per kill of each unique item (per game for a row marked once per game), with “1 in N” kills (or games) in brackets. A dash: the unique cannot drop on that difficulty (Solo: a unique is skipped while the later uniques of its base were not found since you started or loaded the game). Under each chance, the kills or games for 50%: how many give a one-in-two chance of seeing it at least once.

Its quest is only drawn in some new games (“Randomize Quests”, on by default): the chance is the one of a game with the quest, and the counts in games are new games.

Diablo (without Hellfire) · multiplayer

Unique itemBase itemNormalNightmareHell
Baranar's StarMorning Star0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Black RazorDagger0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Blackoak ShieldSmall Shield0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Civerb's CudgelMace0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Constricting RingRing0.432% (1 in 231)0.658% (1 in 152)0.632% (1 in 158)
Ice ShankLong Sword0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
ImmolatorLong Staff0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Leather of AutLeather Armor0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Split Skull ShieldBuckler0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Blackoak BowLong Bow0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The DefenderSabre0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Executioner's BladeFalchion0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The NeedlerShort Bow0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Rainbow CloakCloak0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Torn Flesh of SoulsRags0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Wicked AxeLarge Axe0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Wisdom's WrapRobe0.432% (1 in 231)0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
BloodSlayerBroad Axe—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Bow of the DeadComposite Bow—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Dragon's BreachKite Shield—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Gibbous MoonBroad Sword—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Hammer of JholmMaul—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
Helm of SpiritsHelm—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Celestial AxeBattle Axe—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)
The Celestial StarFlail—0.219% (1 in 456)0.211% (1 in 475)

Chance per kill of each unique item, in brackets as “1 in N” kills. A dash: the unique cannot drop on that difficulty (Solo: a unique is skipped while the later uniques of its base were not found since you started or loaded the game).

Diablo (without Hellfire) · Solo

Unique itemBase itemNormalNightmareHell
The Butcher's Cleaver (once per game)Cleaver100%1 game for 50%——
Stonecleaver (once per game)Broad Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
The Celestial Axe (once per game)Battle Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
Wicked Axe (once per game)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
BloodSlayer (once per game) (after 1 later unique of its base)Broad Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
Sharp Beak (once per game) (after 1 later unique of its base)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%
The Mangler (once per game) (after 2 later uniques of its base)Large Axe—2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%2.7% (1 in 56 games)39 games for 50%

Chance per kill of each unique item (per game for a row marked once per game), with “1 in N” kills (or games) in brackets. A dash: the unique cannot drop on that difficulty (Solo: a unique is skipped while the later uniques of its base were not found since you started or loaded the game). Under each chance, the kills or games for 50%: how many give a one-in-two chance of seeing it at least once.

Its quest is only drawn in some new games (“Randomize Quests”, on by default): the chance is the one of a game with the quest, and the counts in games are new games.

About these numbers

Chance per kill, the same for every character. The item level of the drops is the same on every difficulty; a harder difficulty only widens the list of bases, so some uniques only appear on Nightmare or Hell. In Solo, a unique already found since you started or loaded the game gives way to the previous one of its base. Magic and normal items are not listed here: the calculator gives their odds for any item you type.