Hellfire OddsOdds calculator

The Butcher

Quest in Diablo and Hellfire, Cathedral, level 2. Solo: in 2 games out of 3: each game leaves out one quest of its group (this one, Ogden's Sign or Gharbad The Weak). Multiplayer: in every game. With the host's “Full quests in Multiplayer” option, it is drawn as in Solo (2 games in 3). The Butcher's Cleaver on Normal; on Nightmare and Hell a random axe, always magic (item level 4).

Where
Cathedral, level 2
Quest giver
Wounded Townsman
Boss
The Butcher
Reward
Normal: The Butcher's Cleaver · Nightmare and Hell: a random axe, always magic
Drawn with
Ogden's Sign, Gharbad The Weak
Solo
in 2 games out of 3: each game leaves out one quest of its group (this one, Ogden's Sign or Gharbad The Weak).
Multiplayer
in every game. With the host's “Full quests in Multiplayer” option, it is drawn as in Solo (2 games in 3).

Open The Butcher in the calculator

What to do

  1. The Wounded Townsman, near the cathedral, tells you about the Butcher.
  2. Kill The Butcher in his room on level 2.

Reward odds · Hellfire, Solo

DifficultyRewardPer game with the quest
NormalThe Butcher's Cleaveralways
Nightmare, HellThe Celestial Axe, Wicked Axe, Stonecleaver2.7% each1 in 38
Sharp Beak (after Wicked Axe)2.7%1 in 38
BloodSlayer (after Stonecleaver)2.7%1 in 38
The Mangler (after 2 others of its base)2.7%1 in 38

Reward odds · Hellfire, multiplayer

DifficultyRewardPer game with the quest
NormalThe Butcher's Cleaveralways
Nightmare, HellThe Celestial Axe, Wicked Axe, Stonecleaver2.7% each1 in 38

Multiplayer: only when the host ticks “Full quests in Multiplayer”.

Reward odds · Diablo, Solo

DifficultyRewardPer game with the quest
NormalThe Butcher's Cleaveralways
Nightmare, HellThe Celestial Axe, Wicked Axe, Stonecleaver2.7% each1 in 38
Sharp Beak (after Wicked Axe)2.7%1 in 38
BloodSlayer (after Stonecleaver)2.7%1 in 38
The Mangler (after 2 others of its base)2.7%1 in 38

Reward odds · Diablo, multiplayer

DifficultyRewardPer game with the quest
NormalThe Butcher's Cleaveralways
Nightmare, HellThe Celestial Axe, Wicked Axe, Stonecleaver2.7% each1 in 38

Multiplayer: only when the host ticks “Full quests in Multiplayer”.

On Nightmare and Hell the quest gives a random item of the same type instead of its unique: always magic, good affixes only, and 16% of these items try to be unique. The chance is per game where the quest is done; in Solo a unique marked “after” only comes once those have been found since you started or loaded the game.

Other quests